Our Favorites
Bacon Egg and Cheese
Bacon Egg and Cheese
Chopped Cheese
Chopped Cheese
5. Avocado Toast, Hard Boiled Egg and Tomato
5. Avocado Toast, Hard Boiled Egg and Tomato
Skinny on the Beach Omelette
Hungry Man
Novalicious Sandwich
Novalicious Sandwich
Original Italian
Acai Bowls
Welcome to Bagel & Deli Creations: Bethpage’s Best Bagels & Deli
Looking for the best bagels in Bethpage, NY? Look no further than Bagel & Deli Creations! Voted the #1 bagel and deli shop in the area, we pride ourselves on serving fresh, authentic, hand-rolled NY-style bagels baked warm every single day.
Whether you’re craving a classic egg and cheese breakfast sandwich, a hearty deli hero for lunch, or a fresh cup of coffee, our local Bethpage deli has you covered. Join your neighbors and taste the award-winning difference for yourself. Stop by Bagel & Deli Creations today—where quality ingredients, community, and the best bagels in Long Island meet!
Best Bagels in Bethpage, NY | Bagel & Deli Creations
Welcome to Bagel & Deli Creations, your go-to local deli and bagel shop in Bethpage, NY! Voted the absolute best in town, we serve up authentic, hand-rolled, and freshly baked New York-style bagels every single morning.
Whether you’re stopping by for a classic bacon, egg, and cheese breakfast sandwich, picking up a hearty deli hero for lunch, or need premium catering for your next Long Island event, we’ve got you covered. Experience the unmatched quality, fresh ingredients, and friendly neighborhood service that makes us Bethpage’s favorite morning stop. Visit Bagel & Deli Creations today and taste the award-winning difference!
Come Visit Us
Locally, Owned & Operated Establishment
Good morning, Bethpage! At Bagel & Deli Creations, we’re serving up the most delicious comfort food in town.
Start your morning right with our authentic, hand-rolled bagels or a flavor-packed breakfast wrap, and swing by later for one of our mouthwatering hot grilled sandwiches. There are so many ways to enjoy our menu—grab a quick bite on your morning commute, sit down for a hearty lunch break, or cater your next big family gathering!
Come visit us today at 4153 Hempstead Tpke, Bethpage, NY. It’s our unbeatable daily freshness and welcoming community vibe that make us a true local favorite!
Store Hours
-
Monday
- 05:00 AM - 04:00 PM
- 09:46 PM - 01:45 AM
-
Tuesday
- 05:00 AM - 04:00 PM
- 09:46 PM - 01:45 AM
-
Wednesday
- 05:00 AM - 04:00 PM
- 09:46 PM - 01:45 AM
-
Thursday
- 05:00 AM - 04:00 PM
- 09:46 PM - 01:45 AM
-
Friday
- 05:00 AM - 04:00 PM
- 09:46 PM - 01:45 AM
-
Saturday
- 06:00 AM - 04:00 PM
- 09:46 PM - 01:45 AM
-
Sunday
- 06:00 AM - 04:00 PM
- 09:46 PM - 01:45 AM
See What Customers Say About Us
05/27/2026
05/15/2026
01/17/2026
12/18/2025
10/21/2025
10/07/2025
09/20/2025
09/13/2024
06/07/2024
09/23/2023
11/01/2019
Bagel & Sandwhich Delivery in Bethpage, NY
We are conveniently located right here in Bethpage, NY! If you’re searching for the best bagels near me, stop by our shop at 4153 Hempstead Turnpike. We’re easy to find and the perfect morning stop whether you live right here in town or are commuting through Nassau County.
Yes, we absolutely do! We deliver our fresh, hand-rolled bagels and hearty deli heroes throughout Bethpage and neighboring towns like Levittown, Farmingdale, and Plainview. In fact, our delivery radius covers a huge area! Just order online through our website to see if we can bring breakfast directly to your door.
Our ovens are fired up early! We are open every single day from 5:00 AM to 4:00 PM. Whether you need a quick coffee and breakfast sandwich before the sun comes up, or a hot grilled lunch hero in the afternoon, our local Bethpage team is here ready to serve you.
You sure can. We make it super simple to grab your food on the go. Just click the “Order Online” button right here on our website. You can customize your favorite breakfast wraps, fresh fruit smoothies, or deli sandwiches, and we’ll have everything hot and ready for pickup when you arrive.
Yes! While we proudly pour fresh, hot coffee to get your morning started, we also offer a wide variety of delicious, tasty smoothies. They pair perfectly with our hot grilled sandwiches or breakfast wraps and are a fantastic, refreshing choice for anyone grabbing lunch on Long Island on a warm afternoon.
Absolutely! We are more than just a morning stop. Our deli menu features an incredible selection of hot grilled sandwiches and hearty deli heroes stacked with premium ingredients. If you’re taking a lunch break near Hempstead Turnpike, stop in or order online for the most satisfying midday meal around.
We definitely do! From office breakfasts in Farmingdale to family weekend gatherings right here in Bethpage, our catering menu has you covered. We can prepare beautiful platters of our fresh bagels, signature wraps, and premium deli meats to ensure your guests enjoy the best local flavors Long Island has to offer.
Yes, we want everyone to find something they love! You can easily customize any of our breakfast wraps, hot grilled sandwiches, or salads to fit your preferences. Pairing a lighter wrap with one of our fresh, tasty smoothies is a great way to enjoy a delicious, balanced meal at our deli.
We wouldn’t miss it! Bagel & Deli Creations is open seven days a week, from 5:00 AM to 4:00 PM, Monday through Friday – 6:00 AM – 4:00 PM Saturday and Sunday. We love being a weekend tradition for our Bethpage neighbors, so come on down, grab a dozen warm bagels, and enjoy your weekend the right way.
We offer extensive delivery and catering services far beyond Bethpage, NY! Our massive delivery radius covers almost all zip codes across Nassau and Suffolk Counties, the five boroughs of NYC, and even reaches into New Jersey and Connecticut. Whether you are right here near Hempstead Turnpike or across the bridge, simply enter your zip code at checkout to see if we can bring our fresh bagels right to you.